A list is not a meal
Best restaurants Staten Island is the kind of search that wants a winner. Staten Island is a whole borough, and Hylan Boulevard alone is long enough for a lot of kitchens. This page will not rank them, invent their menus, or hand Brooklyn's Finest Pizza a prize. The useful question is narrower. Do you want to sit down, pick up, or send food to an address near the shop? And is the meal pizza, a hero, pasta, or a plated entrée?
We have been at 1250 Hylan Boulevard, Staten Island, NY 10305 since 2012. The ZIP is 10305, on the East Shore stretch of Hylan, north of New Dorp and Great Kills. If that is the part of the island you are feeding, the rest of this page is the practical version of the search: the menu we actually print, the hours on the door, and how an order moves.
What is on the table
Pizza is the center. The menu lists a classic round cheese pie, a thick crust Sicilian, and grandma's pizza with fresh mozzarella. Specialty large pies include a hot honey roni, a buffalo chicken pizza, a Hawaiian with pineapple and ham, and a cheesesteak pizza topped with steak, tomato sauce, onions, peppers, and cheese. A cheese slice is on the board when you only need one piece. Prices move, so the menu and the ordering site are the numbers that count.
The rest of the kitchen is why people treat the shop like a restaurant and not only a slice window. Neighborhood heroes run from chicken parm to meatball, veal, eggplant, and a Philly cheesesteak hero. Pasta includes baked ziti, fettuccine Alfredo, and pasta with vodka sauce. Entrées such as chicken parmigiana, chicken francese, and eggplant rollatini are served with a salad or pasta. Burgers, wraps, salads, wings, garlic knots, and a short dessert list sit on the same ticket. Kid-friendly plates are listed. So are a personal gluten-free cheese pizza, gluten-free pasta, cauliflower crust, and soy cheese on that crust. Call before you order if someone has an allergy. The kitchen is not an allergen-free room.
Sit down, pick up, or check the radius
The dining room is open during posted hours. Pickup is the counter version of the same food. Delivery is within a 4-mile radius of the shop, and checkout confirms the address. A yes at checkout is a yes. A no means someone is driving to 1250 Hylan Boulevard. Hours are Monday through Thursday 10:00 AM to 10:00 PM, Friday and Saturday 10:00 AM to 10:30 PM, and Sunday 10:30 AM to 10:00 PM. We do not take reservations.
Start at Order Online, which is order.brooklynsfinestsi.com, or call (718) 815-7070 during posted hours. On an iPhone or iPad, the Brooklyn's Finest app sends the same kind of order. If you are comparing best restaurants Staten Island and the real requirement is one menu that covers a pie, a sandwich, and a pasta, start with the full menu or the location page.
When the table gets bigger
A half catering tray serves 6–9 people and a full tray serves 10–15. That is the published portion, and it is the right tool for an office or a house. The catering page lists the trays. A birthday or a family group that should happen in the dining room starts on the parties page: date, head count, and whether you want pies, heroes, or trays. We do not publish a private banquet room or a head-count limit. Call and ask whether that date fits the room.
Current deals live on the specials page. They are the printed NFL, weekend, and catering offers, not a ranking and not a coupon stacked on top of those flyers. Read the flyer prices there. For an ordinary night, the family restaurant page and the Italian restaurant page describe the same kitchen without the 'best of' frame.
Visit the shop
Brooklyn's Finest Pizza is at 1250 Hylan Boulevard, Staten Island, NY 10305. Call (718) 815-7070.
- Monday – Thursday: 10:00 AM – 10:00 PM
- Friday – Saturday: 10:00 AM – 10:30 PM
- Sunday: 10:30 AM – 10:00 PM