October 2, 2026 · Brooklyn's Finest
Hylan is a long table
Hylan Blvd restaurants are not one neighborhood and not one kind of meal. Hylan Boulevard runs the length of Staten Island's East Shore and South Shore, past houses, strip malls, and shopfronts. A person searching that phrase might be in South Beach, Midland Beach, Dongan Hills, New Dorp, Great Kills, or farther down the road, and they might want pizza, a diner breakfast, or a sit-down dinner. This guide does not rank those choices. It tells you how to use the road, and it tells you plainly what Brooklyn's Finest Pizza is.
We will not knock other restaurants. A corridor this long has room for more than one good meal, and a page that invents awards or invents rival menus is not useful. Use hours, the actual menu, and whether you want to sit down or take the food home. Those three facts settle more dinners than a 'best of' list.
Where this shop sits
Brooklyn's Finest Pizza is at 1250 Hylan Boulevard, Staten Island, NY 10305. The ZIP is 10305. The shop has been there since 2012. On a map of Hylan, that puts it on the East Shore stretch, north of New Dorp and Great Kills. If you are already driving the boulevard, the address is a normal stop, not a detour into a side street. The location page has directions.
Call (718) 815-7070 during open hours. Monday through Thursday the shop runs 10:00 AM to 10:00 PM. Friday and Saturday it runs 10:00 AM to 10:30 PM. Sunday it opens at 10:30 AM and closes at 10:00 PM. If a Hylan Blvd restaurant is closed when you arrive, the hour line matters more than the photo.
What kind of meal this is
This is a neighborhood pizzeria with a dining room. The center of the menu is pizza: round cheese pies, a thick crust Sicilian, and a grandma's pie with fresh mozzarella, plus specialty large pies. Around that are neighborhood heroes, pasta, salads, wraps, wings, and 8-ounce burgers. Kid-friendly plates are listed. Gluten-free pizza, gluten-free pasta, cauliflower crust, and soy cheese are listed too. Read the menu for names. Prices on a third-party article go stale, so this one does not quote them.
That mix is why people treat Hylan Blvd restaurants like errands and like nights out at the same time. A pie for the house is an errand. A hero and a seat in the dining room is a night out that does not need a reservation speech. We do not take the shop for a white-tablecloth Italian room, and we do not take it for a delivery app with no address. It is the counter and the room at 1250 Hylan Boulevard.
Drinks stay in pizzeria territory: soda, egg creams, a Manhattan Special, coffee, and a short list on the drinks page. If the meal is 'something sweet with the pie,' an egg cream is the house answer, not a cocktail list.
Sit down, pick up, or check delivery
Three ways to eat from a Hylan address, and they are not the same promise. Sit down in the dining room during posted hours. Pick up after you order online or call. Delivery only within our delivery area, and only if checkout accepts the address. New Dorp and Great Kills are south of the shop. Neighbors there can pick up. This page does not promise a driver to those neighborhoods. Check at checkout.
Online ordering is order.brooklynsfinestsi.com. The Order Online button on this page goes there. It is the same link the rest of the site uses, so you are not guessing which app is the real one.
When you need more than one pie
Hylan Boulevard feeds offices, Little League nights, and Sunday dinners that outgrow a single pizza box. Catering from this kitchen uses half trays for 6–9 people and full trays for 10–15. The catering page is the list. A birthday or a family table that should happen in the room is the parties page: date, head count, pies, heroes, or trays.
If you are choosing among Hylan Blvd restaurants for a group, ask two boring questions. Will everyone eat from this menu, including someone who wants a hero or a gluten-free pie? And do you want the food at the shop or at the house? If the answers are yes and 'either is fine,' 1250 Hylan Boulevard, Staten Island, NY 10305 is a direct option. If you want a different cuisine, keep driving the boulevard. The road is long enough.
A simple way to decide
Look up the hours. Look up the menu. Decide pickup, delivery checkout, or a table. Then go. Brooklyn's Finest Pizza is one restaurant on Hylan Boulevard, Italian-American in the pizzeria sense, open seven days on the schedule above. More pages on this site cover Italian restaurants on Staten Island, pizza for New Dorp pickup, and pizza for Great Kills pickup without pretending those neighborhoods are the storefront.
Bring the order name if you are picking up. Tell the shop about an allergy before you order. And if the plan is a party, call before you print invitations. The dining room is real. It is still one room on Hylan, and the phone is how you find out whether that date works.
Hylan Blvd restaurants also include plenty of places this page will not describe, because we do not have their menus in front of us and we will not invent them. Use their own sites for their hours. Use this site for ours. If the meal you want is pizza, a hero, pasta, or a tray from 1250 Hylan Boulevard, you already have the address, the phone, and the ordering link. That is the whole guide.
Visit the shop
Brooklyn's Finest Pizza is at 1250 Hylan Boulevard, Staten Island, NY 10305. Call (718) 815-7070.
- Monday – Thursday: 10:00 AM – 10:00 PM
- Friday – Saturday: 10:00 AM – 10:30 PM
- Sunday: 10:30 AM – 10:00 PM