Pizza New Dorp, picked up on Hylan
New Dorp sits south of the shop along Hylan Boulevard. Brooklyn's Finest Pizza is not a storefront in the middle of New Dorp Lane. The address is 1250 Hylan Boulevard, Staten Island, NY 10305, in 10305, which is north of New Dorp on the same road. This page is for New Dorp neighbors who want a pie, a hero, or a pasta dinner from this kitchen and are willing to pick it up.
We do not claim delivery to New Dorp from this page. Delivery is available only within our delivery area, and the way to know is to check at checkout. If the ordering site accepts the address, the order can be delivered. If it does not, pickup at 1250 Hylan Boulevard is the plan. Guessing from a neighborhood name is how orders get promised to the wrong block.
What to pick up
The everyday order is a round cheese pie, a Sicilian square, or the grandma's pie with fresh mozzarella. Specialty large pies are on the menu when you want something hotter or more loaded than plain cheese. Garlic knots, wings, and fried calamari are the starters people add when the pie is for more than one person.
Heroes are the other reason New Dorp regulars drive up Hylan. Chicken parm, meatball, veal, eggplant, and the long neighborhood-hero list are made at this counter. Pasta, salads, wraps, and 8-ounce burgers cover the person in the car who does not want pizza. Kid-friendly plates, gluten-free pizza, gluten-free pasta, cauliflower crust, and soy cheese are listed for mixed orders. Call (718) 815-7070 if you need to ask how a dish is made before you leave New Dorp.
Drinks are the short pizzeria list: soda, coffee, a Brooklyn egg cream, a Manhattan Special, Stewart's, and an ice cream soda float. Read the drinks page if that is the part of the order you care about.
How pickup works
Order on Order Online, which is order.brooklynsfinestsi.com, or call the shop during open hours. Put the name on the order, choose pickup, and come to 1250 Hylan Boulevard. The dining room is also open if you would rather eat here than drive the pie back south. Hours are Monday through Thursday 10:00 AM to 10:00 PM, Friday and Saturday 10:00 AM to 10:30 PM, and Sunday 10:30 AM to 10:00 PM.
If you do want delivery, open checkout and enter the address. That screen, not this article, decides whether New Dorp — or a specific block in it — is inside the delivery area. A yes at checkout is a yes. A no means pickup.
Bigger orders from New Dorp
A half catering tray serves 6–9 people and a full tray serves 10–15. Those trays are the practical way to feed a New Dorp house without booking a hall. See catering for the tray list. If the plan is to bring people to the dining room for a birthday, use the parties page and call with the date and the head count.
Pizza New Dorp searches often mix slice shops, chain delivery, and sit-down Italian rooms. This shop is a neighborhood pizzeria that has been on Hylan Boulevard since 2012. Come north to 1250 Hylan Boulevard, Staten Island, NY 10305 for pickup, sit down if you want the room, and use checkout before you count on a driver.
A few practical notes if you are coming from New Dorp Lane or the streets just off Hylan. Order before you get in the car when you can, especially on a Friday or Saturday evening when the counter is moving pies for the whole East Shore. Use the name you put on the ticket. If the order is for a crowd, say so on the phone so trays and pies are not boxed one at a time while you wait at the door. The location page is the map if you have not driven to 10305 before. Nothing on this page is a coupon, a ranking, or a promise that every New Dorp address gets a driver.
Visit the shop
Brooklyn's Finest Pizza is at 1250 Hylan Boulevard, Staten Island, NY 10305. Call (718) 815-7070.
- Monday – Thursday: 10:00 AM – 10:00 PM
- Friday – Saturday: 10:00 AM – 10:30 PM
- Sunday: 10:30 AM – 10:00 PM